Wednesday, May 27, 2009
Is Your Email Marketing Program Hurting Your Business?
Image via Wikipedia
Last year - 2008, early in the year, I bought a new hybrid SUV (not shown) from a Japanese auto maker. It was when gas prices were at a peak. Fuel efficient vehicles, like the Prius (pictured) and similar, were in high demand. I got a little bit off the price. The financing was not as good as if I'd gotten a gas guzzler - such as a truck. In fact, I traded a huge guzzler and took a beating on that end of it. That part may have not worked so well for the dealer either. It sat on their lot for over 60 days.The other day I received another personalized email from the parent company. One of many offers to buy a vehicle. This one offered me a great interest rate plus cash back on a "new" 2008 - the same model as the one I have, which by late in the year they couldn't move.
Frankly... I was peeved. And amazed. I was peeved because it was a better deal of course. But more so because as personal as the email seemed, it showed they ignored what they actually knew about me. It was a total waste of their email marketing loyalty program which quite possibly did more harm than good - that's the part that sort of amazed me. The company has reputation for quality and customer service. I assumed if they had that right, their customer marketing would be done intelligently as well.
Not so much. They offered me the same exact vehicle I already owned, which was one year older now, at a better price & lower interest rate. Now, there was no way they were going to take my current in trade for a new one of the same year - they already had too many and I would be upside down in the deal. No reason I would need to trade, either.
Sure, it's possible I wanted two of the same car, but unlikely. Their offer simply came off as being out of touch and impersonal. All their offers over the last year said "come get another car". This last one really set me off.
Sadly for them there was no need for such a thing to occur. With modern email marketing services they should have multiple lists and much better granularity about my status, current vehicles, how long I'd owned them & more. They would roll me from list to list over time, sending offers appropriate for my situation as a customer. Had they thought, instead, about suggesting upgrades from a dealer?... say... a trailer hitch or a complete luggage rack? Maybe something else related to a driving vacation during last summer or this coming one? What about other options I didn't take originally? Apparently not.
Are you hurting your business with a one size fits all mail list? Join the 21st century.
Use multiple lists. Don't treat prospects the same as customers. Don't treat small customers the same as big ones. Tailor your messages. One service which gives you that kind of flexibility and one we use is Aweber.
True, you have to feed and care for each list. You have to think a little harder. It takes a little more work, time and money (maybe).
Not as much as finding new customers.
Let's Grow!